America's stadium-mob mentality

Welcome, Mates! Post here for General Discussions on how thoroughly sports suck. In general.
User avatar
Fat Man
The Fat Man Judgeth
Posts: 3301
Joined: Fri Feb 13, 2009 5:08 am
Gender: Male
Location: El Paso, Texas, USA, 3rd Planet, Sol System, Milky Way, Local Cluster, Somewhere in The Cosmos!
Contact:

America's stadium-mob mentality

Post by Fat Man »

As for me I don't care to wear sports jerseys of any kind, but because I believe in freedom of speech, I say you got a right to wear a shirt or jersey that says anything you choose. That includes wearing a jersey with the name of the opposite team.

But recently, a young man was arrested and removed from a stadium by police just for wearing the "wrong" kind of jersey.

http://www.salon.com/life/baseball/inde ... 9_7_30_110

Topic:
Baseball
Friday, Aug 6, 2010 21:01 ET
America's stadium-mob mentality
One man's constitutional rights are trampled, and thousands of fans cheer

By David Sirota

Image
Matt Bellamy being removed from
Cleveland's Progressive Field.


One thing you can confidently say about 21st-century America is this: Our icons of seemingly frivolous spectacle often embody deeply significant and disturbing truths. What was Balloon Boy but a deadly serious commentary on national gullibility and misplaced priorities? What was Joe the Plumber but a fun-house reflection of our destructive deification of ignorance? And what was Matt Bellamy last week other than proof that much of our country could care less about its Constitution?

The instantly famous image of police removing the 29-year-old from Cleveland's Progressive Field was largely presented by the media as hilarious and justified â?? and the predictable applause, blog comments, talk-radio calls and Facebook posts embraced that portrayal. Bellamy, the logic went, deserved to be tossed because he was wearing LeBron James' new Miami Heat jersey in the city that James deserted. And not only was Bellamy wearing the jersey, he dared to flaunt it by pointing at it, prompting boos from fans and physical assault via projectile foodstuffs. In response, police say they ejected Bellamy for his own safety.

Before you chime in with a fist-pumping "Good riddance!" remember that Progressive Field is not some private club â?? the taxpayer subsidies that built the stadium effectively make it a public space, ostensibly subjecting it to the Constitution. Also remember that police officers, as taxpayer-funded instruments of state power, are sworn to uphold that Constitution â?? and specifically, the First Amendment's requirement that the state refrain from "abridging the freedom of speech." And remember, too, that Bellamy's jersey didn't run afoul of the few court-authorized exemptions from the First Amendment â?? it didn't, say, violate obscenity statutes or endorse violence.

So while Bellamy was undoubtedly being provocative, that's his constitutional prerogative â?? one that the police officers were obligated to protect. Instead, they removed him, to wild applause, making this event perfectly illustrative of a nation that, for all its pro-Constitution rhetoric, increasingly ignores its founding document.

The First Amendment, after all, doesn't say you have the freedom to say only things that others approve of (or, in this case, wear jerseys that the hometown crowd likes). Nor does it say that, despite your right to free speech, fellow citizens have an equal right to physically assault you if they don't like what you are saying. It doesn't say these things because the framers knew that if government restricts speech on the basis of content, freedom ceases to exist. They also knew that freedom of speech can survive only when government intervenes to defend â?? rather than silence â?? speech.

But in an America that has largely succumbed to the stadium-mob mentality, those are apparently outdated notions â?? even beyond the ballpark walls. This is a country that didn't flinch when the Bush government's spokesperson warned citizens to "watch what they say" â?? just as we didn't flinch when the Obama government's mouthpiece menacingly told Americans to be "exceedingly careful" with their speech. During the 2004 election season, few noticed USA Today's report that "dozens of people" were "banished from or arrested at Bush political rallies," many "simply for holding signs or wearing clothing that expressed opposition to the war and administration policies." In most election campaigns since, just as few citizens seem to care that authorities now confine party convention protesters to "free speech zones" â?? the implication being that there is no First Amendment outside the police-designated cage.

Simply put, we are a country that no longer expresses the outrage that Bellamy rightly voiced after he was ejected from the game.

"I don't understand the reason why they kicked us out," he told reporters. "We paid like everybody, [and] they kicked us out for me wearing what I want to wear."

His anger is warranted. Our silence and cheers speak volumes.

* David Sirota is a nationally syndicated newspaper columnist, bestselling author and host of the morning drive-time radio show on KKZN-AM760.
Here in Texas, our State Board of Education (Indoctrination) voted on textbooks that will be used for the next 10 years. Don McLeory (recently voted out of office) wanted to have any mention of Thomas Jefferson removed from the history text books and to insert creationist fairy tales from Genesis into the science curriculum.

Well, I'm going to order me a couple of extra large T-shirts for myself, one with a picture of Thomas Jefferson on it and another one with the face of Charles Darwin on it.

And I dare anybody to call the cops on me and have me arrested if they don't like what is says on my T-shirts when I go out in public.

COME ON YOU FOOLS!!! BRING IT ON!!!

I'll file such a lawsuit you'll have to sell our homes and cars to pay it off.

I'm spoiling for a good fight, because I could use the money!
ImageI'm fat and sassy! I love to sing & dance & stomp my feet & really rock your world!

All I want to hear from an ex-jock is "Will that be paper or plastic?" After that he can shut the fuck up!
Heah comes da judge! Heah comes da judge! Order in da court 'cuz heah comes da judge!
Image

Image
User avatar
Safety
Sportsman
Posts: 203
Joined: Sat Jul 31, 2010 7:04 pm
Gender: M
Location: Ohio, US

Re: America's stadium-mob mentality

Post by Safety »

I'm from Ohio, and I know how upset off everyone was about LeBron James leaving Cleveland. He wouldn't have been removed if he had just waited a few more months. There's no doubt in my mind that he knew he would get heckled for it, it was a really dumb move by that kid. He probably just wore it to piss people off anyways. To say that his constitutional rights were violated would be wrong. He was removed for his own protection, they do that all the time in stadiums across the country.

Especially at stadiums in Philadelphia.
"I hold that the parentheses are by far the most important parts of a non-business letter." - D. H. Lawrence
User avatar
The Imperialist
Member
Posts: 283
Joined: Sat Jul 31, 2010 4:49 pm
Gender: Male
Location: Guess...

Re: America's stadium-mob mentality

Post by The Imperialist »

Ah yes, but he has every right to do that, and the mob has no right to attack him anyway. That is called assault.
User avatar
i_like_1981
Member
Posts: 1381
Joined: Thu Jan 14, 2010 10:11 pm
Gender: Male
Contact:

Re: America's stadium-mob mentality

Post by i_like_1981 »

The Imperialist wrote:Ah yes, but he has every right to do that, and the mob has no right to attack him anyway. That is called assault.
Safety has a point. By wearing that new jersey, he is provoking the fans there. And I'm pretty sure he was aware of what he was doing. Why would a person go to a game wearing clothes that could most easily get them punched or worse? This guy either lacked common sense or desired an angry response. I'm sure he was more than aware of how belligerent sports fans in city areas can be. This just seems to me like "real life trolling".

Best regards,
i_like_1981
Image

Bernie Rhodes knows don't argue.
User avatar
Fat Man
The Fat Man Judgeth
Posts: 3301
Joined: Fri Feb 13, 2009 5:08 am
Gender: Male
Location: El Paso, Texas, USA, 3rd Planet, Sol System, Milky Way, Local Cluster, Somewhere in The Cosmos!
Contact:

Re: America's stadium-mob mentality

Post by Fat Man »

i_like_1981 wrote:
The Imperialist wrote:Ah yes, but he has every right to do that, and the mob has no right to attack him anyway. That is called assault.
Safety has a point. By wearing that new jersey, he is provoking the fans there. And I'm pretty sure he was aware of what he was doing. Why would a person go to a game wearing clothes that could most easily get them punched or worse? This guy either lacked common sense or desired an angry response. I'm sure he was more than aware of how belligerent sports fans in city areas can be. This just seems to me like "real life trolling".

Best regards,
i_like_1981
Yeah, well, that guy had a legal and constitutional right to wear any kind of jersey he chose, and if the sports fans in the bleachers were merely shouting insults at him and calling him names, then they too would have only been expressing themselves under freedom of speech.

But they crossed the line when they physically assaulted him by throwing stuff at him. Then they went way too far.

Well, I'm going to get a couple of extra large T-shirts with pictures of Thomas Jefferson and Charles Darwin on them and wear them on the streets of El Paso Texas, because I want to deliberately provoke some right-wing whack-jobs on the streets into assaulting me so I can sue them for everything they have and own their houses and their cars.

I would even like for the incident to be shown on ABC NEWS NIGHTLINE, CNN, and even FOX a right-wing broadcast network so that I can own Bill O'riley that right-wing-nut conservatard!
ImageI'm fat and sassy! I love to sing & dance & stomp my feet & really rock your world!

All I want to hear from an ex-jock is "Will that be paper or plastic?" After that he can shut the fuck up!
Heah comes da judge! Heah comes da judge! Order in da court 'cuz heah comes da judge!
Image

Image
User avatar
Safety
Sportsman
Posts: 203
Joined: Sat Jul 31, 2010 7:04 pm
Gender: M
Location: Ohio, US

Re: America's stadium-mob mentality

Post by Safety »

I agree that people shouldn't act so harshly over some sports-related situations, and that people have the right to wear whatever they want, but the kid definitely knew what the crowd's response would be. If you watch the video of him being escorted out of Progressive Field, you can see him shouting back at the crowd, instigating the heckling. You can also see him pulling his jersey out, taunting them.

This video pretty much sums up my point.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=OaMGGWTD_dw
"I hold that the parentheses are by far the most important parts of a non-business letter." - D. H. Lawrence
User avatar
Fat Man
The Fat Man Judgeth
Posts: 3301
Joined: Fri Feb 13, 2009 5:08 am
Gender: Male
Location: El Paso, Texas, USA, 3rd Planet, Sol System, Milky Way, Local Cluster, Somewhere in The Cosmos!
Contact:

Re: America's stadium-mob mentality

Post by Fat Man »

Safety wrote:I agree that people shouldn't act so harshly over some sports-related situations, and that people have the right to wear whatever they want, but the kid definitely knew what the crowd's response would be. If you watch the video of him being escorted out of Progressive Field, you can see him shouting back at the crowd, instigating the heckling. You can also see him pulling his jersey out, taunting them.

This video pretty much sums up my point.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=OaMGGWTD_dw
Yeah! Well, I'm going to go out into the streets of El Paso Texas, and ride the city buses wearing a Charles Darwin T-shirt.

Or I might even have something like this printed on a T-shirt.

Image

Now, isn't he cute!
ImageI'm fat and sassy! I love to sing & dance & stomp my feet & really rock your world!

All I want to hear from an ex-jock is "Will that be paper or plastic?" After that he can shut the fuck up!
Heah comes da judge! Heah comes da judge! Order in da court 'cuz heah comes da judge!
Image

Image
User avatar
Safety
Sportsman
Posts: 203
Joined: Sat Jul 31, 2010 7:04 pm
Gender: M
Location: Ohio, US

Re: America's stadium-mob mentality

Post by Safety »

Fat Man wrote:
Safety wrote:I agree that people shouldn't act so harshly over some sports-related situations, and that people have the right to wear whatever they want, but the kid definitely knew what the crowd's response would be. If you watch the video of him being escorted out of Progressive Field, you can see him shouting back at the crowd, instigating the heckling. You can also see him pulling his jersey out, taunting them.

This video pretty much sums up my point.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=OaMGGWTD_dw
Yeah! Well, I'm going to go out into the streets of El Paso Texas, and ride the city buses wearing a Charles Darwin T-shirt.

Or I might even have something like this printed on a T-shirt.

Image

Now, isn't he cute!
It's not that he wore a LeBron James Miami Heat jersey to a baseball game, it's that he wore it at a baseball game in Cleveland. Wear that shirt into a church and you might get the same reaction.
"I hold that the parentheses are by far the most important parts of a non-business letter." - D. H. Lawrence
User avatar
Fat Man
The Fat Man Judgeth
Posts: 3301
Joined: Fri Feb 13, 2009 5:08 am
Gender: Male
Location: El Paso, Texas, USA, 3rd Planet, Sol System, Milky Way, Local Cluster, Somewhere in The Cosmos!
Contact:

Re: America's stadium-mob mentality

Post by Fat Man »

Safety wrote: Image

It's not that he wore a LeBron James Miami Heat jersey to a baseball game, it's that he wore it at a baseball game in Cleveland. Wear that shirt into a church and you might get the same reaction.
Nah! I just have to wear that shirt anywhere in Texas!

Or Arkansas, or Mississippi, or Louisiana, or Kentucky, or any southern state, and Somebody will want to kick my fat ass!

I can see myself 10 years from now making a fortune selling bootleg books, copies of Charles Darwin's Origin of The Species or Carl Sagan's Cosmos, or just about any book that might be banned in the future. Since those books will probably be banned in Texas or in the Southern USA, then, well, who knows? I might become the new Al Capone of Literature.

Yeah! I can see it now!

Back in the 1930s when we had the prohibition against liquor, some people set up underground bars called "Speak Easys" of "Blind pigs" while I would set up underground libraries called "Read Easys" or "Seeing Eye Dogs" and traffic in bootleg books will be referred to as "book-legging" and I would set up an underground printing press.

Yeah! That will give a whole new meaning to "Making Book" or "Book Making" Yeah! I can see it now!

The way this country is going, nothing will surprise me!

I'll make the MAFIA look like a bunch of girl scouts at a church picnic by comparison!

OK, this is just a twisted and warped fantasy of mine!

Hey! This would make good material for a novel about some futuristic society, sort of like Fahrenheit 451, which incidentally, had been banned from some school libraries back in the 1980s during the Reagan Presidency.
ImageI'm fat and sassy! I love to sing & dance & stomp my feet & really rock your world!

All I want to hear from an ex-jock is "Will that be paper or plastic?" After that he can shut the fuck up!
Heah comes da judge! Heah comes da judge! Order in da court 'cuz heah comes da judge!
Image

Image
User avatar
i_like_1981
Member
Posts: 1381
Joined: Thu Jan 14, 2010 10:11 pm
Gender: Male
Contact:

Re: America's stadium-mob mentality

Post by i_like_1981 »

Fat Man wrote:Yeah, well, that guy had a legal and constitutional right to wear any kind of jersey he chose, and if the sports fans in the bleachers were merely shouting insults at him and calling him names, then they too would have only been expressing themselves under freedom of speech.

But they crossed the line when they physically assaulted him by throwing stuff at him. Then they went way too far.
Well, yes, obviously he was not breaking the law by wearing that jersey. He does have his freedom of choice to wear what he wants. But not wearing the new strip of one of the area's top players who has recently moved somewhere else is just common sense. It was an inappropriate decision. Just because something's not illegal doesn't necessarily mean it's wise to do. Over here in England our football fans are touchy about their top local sports players and their plans. If I were to go into the home ground of one of our top football teams doing something along the lines of what that guy did, I wouldn't expect to be arrested. But I sure as hell WOULD expect to be assaulted. And I expect the people there would not interpret it as a simple mistake of putting the wrong shirt on inadvertently, but as trying to provoke them into getting angry. Besides, I know for a fact that people over here keep a very close eye on what they choose to wear at football matches. Wearing the wrong thing can get you punched. It's illegal to assault someone over what clothes they wear but at a football match, it's most likely to happen if you wear the wrong shirt. You HAVE to tread carefully. And people know what they're getting into when they go to one of these football matches. Football matches over here are rowdy. Riots start. We have a "hooligan" subculture of people who go round trying to start as many fights as they can. To sum up, I'm not surprised that this guy in the new Lebron James jersey didn't get a nice reception, and although the reaction of the home fans wasn't admirable, it was provoked.

Best regards,
i_like_1981
Image

Bernie Rhodes knows don't argue.
User avatar
The Imperialist
Member
Posts: 283
Joined: Sat Jul 31, 2010 4:49 pm
Gender: Male
Location: Guess...

Re: America's stadium-mob mentality

Post by The Imperialist »

Well, part fo the problem is that people cannot ignore a expression that they think is incovienient for them (jocks, anybody?).
User avatar
HugeFanOfBadReligion
Member
Posts: 545
Joined: Tue Mar 30, 2010 11:36 pm
Gender: Male
Location: Canada

Re: America's stadium-mob mentality

Post by HugeFanOfBadReligion »

This is providing me with ideas on how to anger sports fans. Perhaps I should do this. The only problem is I'd have to find out about a sports player that played on a team from my area and I'd need to pay for a stupid ticket to see some idiots run around on a court. Perhaps I could just somehow get a jersey from one of the other local highschools and wear it to my school and flag it around and see the reaction.
"Mensa membership conceding, tell my why and how are all the stupid people breeding?" - The Idiots Are Taking Over - NOFX

"Basis of change: educate - derived from discussion, not hate, not myth, not muscle, not etiquette" - Hate, Myth, Muscle, Etiquette - Propagandhi

"We need to teach our kids that it's not just the winner of the Superbowl who deserves to be celebrated, but the winner of the science fair" - Barack Obama
User avatar
Lewis
Member
Posts: 607
Joined: Sun Feb 15, 2009 5:16 pm
Gender: Male
Location: UK

Re: America's stadium-mob mentality

Post by Lewis »

i_like_1981 wrote:
Fat Man wrote:Yeah, well, that guy had a legal and constitutional right to wear any kind of jersey he chose, and if the sports fans in the bleachers were merely shouting insults at him and calling him names, then they too would have only been expressing themselves under freedom of speech.

But they crossed the line when they physically assaulted him by throwing stuff at him. Then they went way too far.
Well, yes, obviously he was not breaking the law by wearing that jersey. He does have his freedom of choice to wear what he wants. But not wearing the new strip of one of the area's top players who has recently moved somewhere else is just common sense. It was an inappropriate decision. Just because something's not illegal doesn't necessarily mean it's wise to do. Over here in England our football fans are touchy about their top local sports players and their plans. If I were to go into the home ground of one of our top football teams doing something along the lines of what that guy did, I wouldn't expect to be arrested. But I sure as hell WOULD expect to be assaulted. And I expect the people there would not interpret it as a simple mistake of putting the wrong shirt on inadvertently, but as trying to provoke them into getting angry. Besides, I know for a fact that people over here keep a very close eye on what they choose to wear at football matches. Wearing the wrong thing can get you punched. It's illegal to assault someone over what clothes they wear but at a football match, it's most likely to happen if you wear the wrong shirt. You HAVE to tread carefully. And people know what they're getting into when they go to one of these football matches. Football matches over here are rowdy. Riots start. We have a "hooligan" subculture of people who go round trying to start as many fights as they can. To sum up, I'm not surprised that this guy in the new Lebron James jersey didn't get a nice reception, and although the reaction of the home fans wasn't admirable, it was provoked.

Best regards,
i_like_1981
I was once told that a man in Liverpool was stabbed to death, because he wore a Manchester United shirt. What a terrible thing to happen, there are some evil people in the world.
Image
User avatar
i_like_1981
Member
Posts: 1381
Joined: Thu Jan 14, 2010 10:11 pm
Gender: Male
Contact:

Re: America's stadium-mob mentality

Post by i_like_1981 »

For just wearing a shirt that is absolutely unjustifiable. With things like this happening, people losing their lives because they dare to show their admiration for a non-local team, it's no wonder why I never showed an interest in football. There seem to be so many football fans around in the UK nowadays who absolutely can't stand "outsiders". Shame that our country has come to this, but things like this have been going on for years. You should check the Life on Mars episode revolving around the murder of a Manchester United fan (I think it was Series 1, Episode 5) to see the true idiocy and bloodlust of the dark side of British football culture.

Best regards,
i_like_1981
Image

Bernie Rhodes knows don't argue.
User avatar
Fat Man
The Fat Man Judgeth
Posts: 3301
Joined: Fri Feb 13, 2009 5:08 am
Gender: Male
Location: El Paso, Texas, USA, 3rd Planet, Sol System, Milky Way, Local Cluster, Somewhere in The Cosmos!
Contact:

Re: America's stadium-mob mentality

Post by Fat Man »

Lewis wrote:I was once told that a man in Liverpool was stabbed to death, because he wore a Manchester United shirt. What a terrible thing to happen, there are some evil people in the world.
Oh WOW!

Imagine someone getting stabbed to death just for wearing the "wrong" kind of jersey!

That is really sick!

No, not just sick, but absolutely EVIL!!!

That's it! I'm now convinced that sports should be made illegal around the world.

Sorry, but no more football, no more soccer, no more basketball, no more sports of any kind.

All of these sports nuts should be rounded up and placed in re-education camps and not be released until they have made passing grades in history, sociology, political science, the Constitution and the Magna Carta, and any history about human rights, also math courses in Algebra, Geometry, and Trigonometry and science, and how to act like human beings.

Only after making passing grades in all high school level subjects, then upon graduation can they be released from the re-education camps when they have learned to act like human beings.

The ones who fail, if they are too fucking moronic and retarded to pass ALL of these courses, then they should be put to sleep by lethal injection, and their bodies properly disposed of, buried in unmarked graves.

OK! Does this sound Fascist?

You're damn right it's Fascist!!!

But most sports fans are Fascist anyway, so if it's Fascism they want, then I'll give them Fascism!!!

I'll give then exactly what they like!

FASCISM!!!

End of story!!!
ImageI'm fat and sassy! I love to sing & dance & stomp my feet & really rock your world!

All I want to hear from an ex-jock is "Will that be paper or plastic?" After that he can shut the fuck up!
Heah comes da judge! Heah comes da judge! Order in da court 'cuz heah comes da judge!
Image

Image
Post Reply